Generally, it is not advisable to keep students after school for forgetting their homework if it is the first time it happens. Instead, it is best to talk to the student and try to understand why they forgot their homework. This could be a simple oversight, or it could point to some underlying academic or personal issues that need to be addressed. In such cases, it can be more effective to provide the student with support and resources to help them succeed, rather than punishment that could further discourage them.
However, there may be cases where keeping students after school is appropriate, such as when the student has a history of forgetting their homework and has received multiple reminders. In these cases, keeping them after school may serve as a reminder of their responsibility to complete and turn in their work. It can also provide an opportunity for the student to complete their missing assignment and get extra support from the teacher if needed.
Some educators argue that keeping students after school for forgetting their homework can be counterproductive, as it can lead to increased stress and anxiety, which may hinder their ability to focus and learn. Others argue that it teaches students the importance of responsibility and accountability.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to keep students after school for forgetting their homework should be made on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the student's individual circumstances and the school's policies and expectations.