While Paine didn't specifically call it "war and massacre", his argument in "American Crisis No. 1" revolved around the following key points:
* Justifying the Revolution: Paine argues that the American colonists had a moral and just cause to rebel against British rule. He presents the British government as tyrannical and oppressive, listing grievances like unjust taxation without representation and violation of fundamental rights.
* Appealing to Morality and Justice: He uses strong emotional language and appeals to the sense of justice and morality in his readers. He frames the conflict as a struggle for freedom, liberty, and self-determination against tyranny.
* Emphasizing the Need for Action: He urges colonists to join the fight for independence, arguing that inaction and apathy would be tantamount to surrendering their freedom.
* Denouncing Hesitation and Doubt: Paine criticizes those who are hesitant or fearful of the war, calling them "summer soldiers" and "sunshine patriots" who are only willing to fight when things are easy.
* Highlighting the Benefits of Independence: Paine paints a vivid picture of the potential benefits of a free and independent America, emphasizing the opportunity for prosperity, self-governance, and a better future for future generations.
Overall, Paine's argument was a powerful call to action, aimed at inspiring the colonists to rise up against British rule and fight for their independence. He was instrumental in shaping public opinion and building support for the revolutionary cause through his passionate and persuasive writings.