Academic achievement awards will mostly be based on a student's grades and effort in a single subject. You should also award students that have noticeably improved their grades and demonstrate a strong commitment to a certain subject. Examples of academic achievement awards may include: Spelling Champion, Young Scientist, Math Genius, Ravenous Reader, Young Artist, Musical Prodigy, Computer Wizard, Most Improved Grades (one award for each major subject).
Academic talent awards represent the qualities that can't be quantified purely through grades. If a student demonstrates behavior that enhances the learning environment, or extends her education beyond the curriculum (participation in the school play or band) she should be awarded for it. Some ideas for the academic talent category may include: Most Curious, Most Creative, The Class Citizen, Best Storyteller, Most Dramatic/Best Performer, Best Singer and Natural Group Leader.
Athletic talent awards should take into consideration a student's participation in compulsory physical education classes as well as after school sports and activities. Award ideas for the athletic talent category can include: Best Overall Athlete (girl/boy), Best Dancer, Best Team Player, Best Outdoorsperson/Hiker, Best at Soccer/Basketball/Baseball/Volleyball/Track & Field/Tennis/Swimming (one award per sport).
The character awards category is the most objective. Focus on a student's most unique characteristics; the award should seem tailor made for him. If the school is faith-based, this category can include awards for students who lead prayer time or participate in chapel activities. More ideas for character awards include: Neatest Handwriting, Perfect Attendance, Most Organized, Best Manners, Most Helpful, Comedian of the Year, Future Filmmaker, Future Politician, Young Entrepreneur, Young Philanthropist, Friend of the Earth Award, Most Enthusiastic and Best Style.