1. Message and Theme:
- Beasts of England: This song represents the initial utopian vision and revolutionary spirit of the animals. It's a call for equality, freedom, and the overthrow of human tyranny. It embodies the ideals of the rebellion and serves as an anthem of hope and change.
- Comrade Napoleon: In contrast, "Comrade Napoleon" is a satirical and critical song that reflects the transformation of Napoleon into a dictatorial leader. It highlights the irony and hypocrisy of the pigs' actions, who have become the very oppressors they once fought against.
2. Lyrical Content:
- Beasts of England: The lyrics of "Beasts of England" are full of powerful imagery and metaphors, such as "no voice but wind of hurrying wings" and "no sound but dropping tears." It presents a compelling vision of a better future and inspires the animals to rise against their oppressors.
- Comrade Napoleon: "Comrade Napoleon" uses parody, irony, and wordplay to ridicule Napoleon and his followers. The lyrics satirically praise Napoleon as a "father" and "protector" while subtly critiquing his authoritarian rule.
3. Tone and Mood:
- Beasts of England: The tone of "Beasts of England" is optimistic, passionate, and filled with a sense of unity and purpose. It creates an atmosphere of hope and anticipation for positive change.
- Comrade Napoleon: "Comrade Napoleon" has a cynical, mocking, and almost bitter tone. It reflects the disillusionment and disappointment of the animals as they witness the corruption and betrayal of their leaders.
4. Impact on the Plot:
- Beasts of England: "Beasts of England" serves as a catalyst for the rebellion and motivates the animals to take action against Mr. Jones.
- Comrade Napoleon: "Comrade Napoleon" signals the complete shift in power dynamics on the farm and cements Napoleon's dictatorial control.
In summary, while "Beasts of England" represents the revolutionary spirit and ideals of the animals, "Comrade Napoleon" satirically critiques the descent into tyranny and corruption on the farm. These two songs provide contrasting viewpoints and highlight the complex themes and shifts that occur throughout the novel.