- Identify the author's background, affiliations, and potential conflicts of interest.
- Is the author an expert in the field?
- Do they have any personal or professional connections to the issue or people involved?
- Have they written or spoken on the topic before?
- Examine the language and tone of the piece.
- Does the author use inflammatory or biased language?
- Are they dismissive of opposing viewpoints?
- Do they present a fair and balanced analysis of the issue?
Level of Knowledge or Expertise
- Check for evidence of the author's knowledge and expertise on the topic.
- Do they cite credible sources?
- Do they demonstrate a deep understanding of the issue?
- Do they present new insights or ideas?
- Consider the author's qualifications and experience.
- Do they have academic credentials in the relevant field?
- Have they worked in the field or with affected communities?
- Are they respected by peers and experts in the field?