What did people think about Edgar Allan writing?

The reception to Edgar Allan Poe's writing during his lifetime and the years immediately following it was rather complex and varied. While he was recognized for his unique literary talents and distinct writing style, he also had to contend with both widespread acclaim and harsh criticism. Here's a summary of what contemporaries and critics of his time had to say about Edgar Allan Poe's writing:

1. The Early Years:

- During the earlier stages of his career, Poe's works received limited attention and recognition from the general public.

2. Tales of Mystery and Horror:

- Poe is best known for his masterful tales of mystery and the macabre. Many critics praised his ability to create a tense atmosphere and evoke strong emotions of dread and suspense.

- His short stories, such as "The Tell-Tale Heart" and "The Fall of the House of Usher," were particularly well-received for their haunting and eerie imagery.

3. Influential Style and Craft:

- Many literary critics and writers recognized and appreciated the originality of Poe's writing style. His mastery over language and creation of rhythm, along with his use of sound and imagery, were widely commended.

4. Lack of Moral Guidance:

- Some critics criticized Poe's works for being pessimistic and lacking in a clear moral or didactic message. They argued that he focused excessively on death and despair, potentially influencing readers negatively.

5. Excessive Dark Themes:

- Several reviewers found Poe's preoccupation with dark and morbid subjects to be disturbing or excessive. Some contemporary audiences preferred a more uplifting and optimistic tone in their literature.

6. Lack of Popularity in the US vs. Europe:

- Ironically, Poe's works gained more significant popularity and admiration in Europe compared to his native United States during his lifetime. European critics were more sympathetic to his unconventional literary themes.

7. Influence on Literature:

- Despite some criticisms, Edgar Allan Poe is widely regarded as one of the pioneers of the detective fiction and horror genres. His writings heavily influenced later generations of authors.

8. Legacy and Impact:

- In later years, Poe's reputation grew posthumously as writers and critics came to appreciate the complexity, depth, and symbolist elements in his works. He is now considered a master of American literature and one of the most important figures in the development of short stories and horror fiction.

Overall, Edgar Allan Poe's writing elicited both praise and criticism during his time, with some detractors finding his works too dark and morally dubious, while others found them deeply compelling and innovative. His lasting influence on subsequent writers and genres, however, solidifies his position as a literary icon whose contributions continue to resonate in the world of literature and beyond.