Hearsay and Speculation: The conclusion of the story relies heavily on hearsay and speculation from the townspeople, who often pass judgment on Emily Grierson and her life. The narrator presents the events and opinions of the townspeople without providing concrete evidence or検証. This reliance on hearsay can lead to inaccuracies and biases, affecting the reliability of the conclusion.
Limited Perspectives: The story is primarily narrated from the perspective of the townspeople and does not provide a clear understanding of Emily's inner thoughts, motivations, or experiences. The conclusion is drawn based on the limited perspectives of the narrator and the townspeople, which may not fully capture the complexities of Emily's character and actions.
Incomplete Information: The story leaves significant gaps in Emily's life and the events leading to her final moments. The cause of her death, her relationship with Homer Barron, and the reason behind her behavior and choices remain largely unexplained. This lack of complete information makes it challenging to form a definitive conclusion about Emily's actions and motivations.
Sudden Revelation: The conclusion introduces an unexpected revelation regarding the body in Emily's house, which seems to drastically change the perception of her character. This last-minute revelation may feel abrupt and could be seen as a plot device rather than a natural progression of the story, making the conclusion appear contrived or forced.
Absence of Closure: The story ends abruptly without providing a sense of closure or resolution. It leaves many questions unanswered, such as what happened to Emily's family, her relationship with the town, and the consequences of her actions. This lack of closure can leave readers feeling unsatisfied with the conclusion.
Overall, the conclusion of "A Rose for Emily" can be seen as flawed because it relies heavily on hearsay, limited perspectives, incomplete information, and a sudden revelation without providing a satisfying sense of closure. These factors contribute to a sense of ambiguity and uncertainty, making the conclusion open to multiple interpretations and discussions.