* Kaplan: Often praised for its clear explanations and well-structured practice questions. It tends to focus on a good balance between content review and practice, making it a solid choice for most students. It's generally considered more user-friendly than Barron's.
* Barron's: Known for its extensive practice questions, often exceeding the difficulty level of the actual SAT Subject Tests. This can be beneficial for aiming for a high score, but it might also be overwhelming or discouraging for some students. The content review can be dense and less user-friendly than Kaplan's.
* Princeton Review: Falls somewhere in between Kaplan and Barron's. It usually provides a decent amount of practice questions and clear explanations, but generally doesn't go to the extremes of either Kaplan's ease of use or Barron's difficulty. They often emphasize test-taking strategies.
Here's a breakdown to help you decide:
* If you prefer a clear, straightforward approach with a good balance of content review and practice: Kaplan is likely a better choice.
* If you want extensive practice, even if it means dealing with harder questions than you'll see on the test, and don't mind a more dense textbook: Barron's might be suitable. This is good for aiming for a very high score, but be prepared for a potentially more challenging experience.
* If you want a middle ground between the two extremes: The Princeton Review could be a good option.
Ultimately, the best way to choose is to:
1. Look at sample pages: See which book's writing style and question format you find most engaging and easy to understand.
2. Read reviews: Check online reviews from other students who have used these books for the specific subject test you're taking.
3. Consider your current knowledge level: If you're already quite strong in the subject, Barron's might be a good challenge. If you need more foundational review, Kaplan might be better.
Remember that no single prep book guarantees a high score. Consistent study and practice are key. You might even find it helpful to use multiple resources to supplement your learning.