Independent Study (like John Vierra's, if it exists):
* Pros: Might offer more structure and support than homeschooling. Potentially provides access to resources and curriculum not available at home. Could allow for more socialization with other students than homeschooling. May be perceived as a "step up" from homeschooling by some colleges.
* Cons: Might still lack the full range of extracurricular activities and social interaction of a public school. The level of support and quality of instruction can vary greatly depending on the program. May still require significant parental involvement. May not be accredited at the same level as a public school, potentially affecting college applications.
Homeschooling:
* Pros: Complete control over curriculum and pace. Potentially stronger parent-child bond. Flexibility to tailor education to individual learning styles and interests.
* Cons: Requires significant parental time and commitment. May limit socialization opportunities. Can be challenging to replicate the resources and expertise of a public school.
Considering your situation:
You wanted public school, but that's not an option. Independent study *might* offer a better approximation of the public school experience than homeschooling, depending on the specific program.
To decide if John Vierra's independent study program is right for you, consider these questions:
* What specific program is offered? Research the curriculum, teaching methods, and support services.
* What is the level of interaction with other students and teachers? Is it mostly self-directed, or is there a structured learning environment with regular interaction?
* Is it accredited? Accreditation is crucial for college applications.
* What are the costs involved? Independent study programs can be expensive.
* How much parental involvement is required? Is this a realistic expectation for your family?
If possible, contact the John Vierra program directly and ask detailed questions. Compare its offerings to homeschooling options available to you. Ultimately, the "better" choice will depend on your specific needs and the resources available.