Should colleges accept students with high test scores or strong extracurricular backgrounds?

Colleges should consider both high test scores and strong extracurricular backgrounds when accepting students. Neither should be the sole determinant. A holistic review process that considers a wide range of factors, including grades, essays, letters of recommendation, and demonstrated potential, is generally considered the best approach. High test scores might indicate academic aptitude, while strong extracurriculars demonstrate commitment, leadership, and other valuable skills. The ideal applicant possesses a strong combination of both.