There is no single answer to this question, as the best extracurricular activities for a particular college application will vary depending on the student's interests, strengths, and goals.
However, in general, colleges tend to appreciate students who are involved in a variety of extracurricular activities, including arts, sports, and community service. So, if a student is passionate about music and has dedicated a lot of time to it, either through band or choir, then that extracurricular activity could certainly help to support their college application.
Ultimately, the best way to decide whether band or choir (or both!) is a good extracurricular activity for a college application is to consider
- The student's individual interests and passions
- The amount of time and dedication they are willing to invest in the activity
- How the activity contributes to their overall development and future goals.