* Theatre World Award for Outstanding Broadway Debut (Andrea McArdle) (1977)
* Obie Award for Outstanding Musical Production (1976)
* Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Musical (1977)
* Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Book of a Musical (Thomas Meehan) (1977)
* Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Lyrics (Martin Charnin) (1977)
* Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album (1977)
* Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album (1977)
* Los Angeles Drama Critics Circle Award for Best Musical (1977)
* Outer Critics Circle Award for Best Musical (1977)
* Village Voice Obie Award for Best American Play (1976)