In "The Ax-Helve", the speaker reflects on the cyclical nature of life and death, using the image of the ax-helve as a symbol of this cycle. The poem suggests that even though the ax-helve is worn down and eventually replaced, its essence is passed on to the next generation. This cyclical view offers a sense of comfort in the face of death, suggesting that even in death, something endures.
"Out, Out—", on the other hand, presents a more stark and tragic view of death. The poem's focus on the young boy's sudden and unexpected death emphasizes the cruelty and capriciousness of fate. There is a sense of shock and loss, as the boy's life is abruptly cut short. This poem doesn't offer any comforting cyclical view like "The Ax-Helve". It simply presents the harsh reality of death and its impact on those left behind.
While both poems acknowledge the inevitability of death, "The Ax-Helve" provides a more nuanced and accepting view, while "Out, Out—" highlights the tragic and random nature of death.
Here's a breakdown of the central messages:
* "The Ax-Helve": Life and death are intertwined, part of a cyclical process. Even in death, something endures.
* "Out, Out—": Death can be sudden and brutal, shattering the lives of those left behind. Life is fragile and unpredictable.