Tragedy: The poem narrates a heartbreaking tale of love, betrayal, and death. The young man's love for Barbara Allan is unrequited, leading to his demise. The poem depicts a tragic loss of life and the devastating consequences of pride and misunderstanding.
Sorrow: The poem is deeply melancholic, filled with expressions of sorrow and grief. The young man's lament for Barbara Allan is infused with pain and longing. Her own regret and realization of her love too late adds another layer of profound sorrow.
Regret: Barbara Allan experiences deep remorse for her actions and the consequences they have brought. Her regret is evident in her actions, like sending for the young man and her final words.
Acceptance: The poem ends on a note of acceptance, even though it remains deeply tragic. Barbara Allan's death and the young man's mournful burial signify that life moves on, even after devastating loss. There is a sense of resignation to the inevitable.
Overall, the mood of "Bonny Barbara Allan" is somber, melancholic, and ultimately tragic. It explores the complexities of human emotions, the consequences of pride and miscommunication, and the enduring nature of sorrow and regret.