Where did Edgar Allan Poe get his idea of the talking raven for poem from English writer Charles dickens bird whom named grip originally appeared in what novel?

While it's true that Charles Dickens had a pet raven named Grip who appeared in his novel "Barnaby Rudge" (1841), there's no direct evidence that Edgar Allan Poe got the idea for his poem "The Raven" (1845) from Dickens' bird.

Here's what we know:

* Poe's poem is a work of dark romanticism and gothic horror, while Dickens' novel is a historical fiction. The context and tone of the two works are very different.

* The raven in "Barnaby Rudge" is more of a comic character, a talking pet bird. The raven in "The Raven" is a dark, ominous symbol of loss and grief.

* There's no documented evidence that Poe ever read "Barnaby Rudge" or saw Dickens' raven. Although Poe was aware of Dickens' work and may have heard about Grip, there's no proof of a direct connection.

While Dickens' raven might have influenced Poe subconsciously, it's more likely that Poe drew inspiration from various sources:

* His own experiences with loss and grief: Poe was deeply affected by the death of his young wife, Virginia, and his poem is considered a reflection of his own emotional turmoil.

* Folklore and mythology: Ravens have long been associated with death, prophecy, and the supernatural in various cultures, giving Poe a rich symbolic palette to work with.

* Contemporary literature: Poe was a voracious reader and was likely familiar with other gothic and macabre literature that featured talking birds or other supernatural elements.

Ultimately, the source of Poe's inspiration for "The Raven" remains a topic of debate among scholars. While Dickens' raven might have been a small spark, it's not the definitive answer.