* Joe Gargery: Joe is Pip's kind and loving brother-in-law, who always supports him, even when Pip rejects his humble life. He provides Pip with a stable home and a sense of belonging.
* Herbert Pocket: Herbert is Pip's friend and confidant, always offering support and encouragement. He is genuinely happy for Pip's success and helps him navigate the challenges of his new life.
* Miss Havisham: This is a more complex case. Though cruel and manipulative, Miss Havisham does show a twisted form of kindness towards Pip. She gives him opportunities and helps him develop, even if her methods are destructive.
* Estella: While not particularly kind, Estella's coldness and disdain do ultimately motivate Pip to grow and learn. Her rejection pushes him to strive for improvement and ultimately leads him to understand the true value of human connection.
Ultimately, who you consider the kindest depends on your interpretation of the novel. Each character contributes to Pip's journey in their own unique way, and their "kindness" can be seen through different lenses.