The Kite Runner:
* Themes: Redemption, guilt, forgiveness, family, betrayal, and the impact of the past on the present.
* Ending: The ending is emotionally powerful and bittersweet. Amir finally confronts his past and makes a difficult choice to save Sohrab, the son of his childhood friend Hassan, from a life of misery. While there's a sense of closure and redemption for Amir, there are lingering questions about Sohrab's future and the unresolved trauma of the past.
* Why some might prefer it: It's a deeply moving ending that leaves a lasting impression, prompting reflection on themes of personal responsibility and the possibility of redemption.
A Complicated Kindness:
* Themes: Family, community, resilience, loss, the impact of prejudice, and the importance of empathy.
* Ending: The ending is more hopeful and open-ended. It focuses on the power of hope and community, with the characters finding solace and strength in each other amidst difficult times. It suggests that even though they face challenges, there's a possibility for a brighter future.
* Why some might prefer it: It offers a sense of hope and optimism that can be uplifting. The open-ended nature allows readers to imagine the possibilities for the characters' future.
Ultimately, the "better" ending depends on your individual preferences and what you find most satisfying.
Here are some questions to consider when deciding which ending you prefer:
* Do you prefer a clear resolution or a more open-ended conclusion?
* What are your thoughts on the themes and messages of each novel?
* Which ending evokes a stronger emotional response in you?
There's no right or wrong answer - both novels offer powerful and thought-provoking conclusions.