#  >> K-12 >> K-12 For Educators

Rights in Prescriptive & Descriptive English

Linguists' and grammarians' understanding of language has fundamentally transformed over the years. In the field of language and linguistics, there has been a movement away from the conventional, prescriptive tradition toward a more descriptive understanding of English. With this transition, there has been a transition of "right" or authority with respect to language and its function.
  1. Overview of Prescriptive English

    • Descriptive English and prescriptive English reflect two fundamentally opposing perspectives of the English language, the function of language and approaches to studying language. According to descriptive linguists and grammarians, English should be studied descriptively. Linguists and grammarians should undertake to study what English (language, more broadly) is, how it is used, what its forms are and how it functions in different contexts.

    Overview of Descriptive Language

    • In contrast to descriptive English, prescriptive English is primarily considered with what English (or language, generally) should be, how it should be used, what its forms should be and how it should function. Prescriptive linguists approach language as a means of enforcing certain societal and syntactical standards of communication. Presciptivists adhere to classical traditions of language, aiming to preserve structured forms of language as sacred and whole.

    Rights in Presciptive English

    • Prescriptivists endow language (rather than the people that use language) with authority. Speakers and users of language are deprived of rights to manipulate language; rather, they are obligated to uphold conventional, structured standards of language. Problematically, structured language cannot enforce itself. Traditionally, grammarians and linguists, therefore, have assumed the right of authority to determine appropriate and inappropriate uses of language, writing dictionaries, thesauruses and other reference texts to provide the rules for "correct" language.

    Rights in Descriptive English

    • Descriptivists acknowledge language as an organic form, changing and adapting to meet the communicative needs of the people that use it. Therefore, the "rights" or authority are assigned to communicants. Descriptivists recognize slang and other violations of conventional grammar as valid forms. After all, descriptivists understand language as a medium, so there exist no correct and incorrect uses of language. Spelling, grammar, pronunciation and syntax are studied to help linguists understand how these features are being used and adapted, but these aspects of language are not used to promote or enforce standards.

Learnify Hub © www.0685.com All Rights Reserved