* Most commercially successful? "The Raven" is likely the most recognized and widely read, though it wasn't initially a huge commercial hit.
* Most critically acclaimed? Many critics consider "The Tell-Tale Heart" to be a masterpiece of horror, while others praise his poetry collections like "The Raven and Other Poems" and "Al Aaraaf, Tamlane, and Other Poems" for their lyrical beauty.
* Most influential? Poe's detective stories featuring C. Auguste Dupin are considered foundational in the genre of detective fiction.
However, if we're talking about overall impact and enduring legacy, it's a close call between "The Raven" (1845) and "The Tell-Tale Heart" (1843). Both have had a profound influence on literature, film, music, and popular culture.
Here's a brief breakdown:
* "The Raven": Its dark and haunting imagery, memorable rhyme scheme, and exploration of themes of loss and grief made it an instant sensation. It's arguably the most famous poem in the English language and has been adapted countless times.
* "The Tell-Tale Heart": This short story is considered a masterclass in psychological horror, with its vivid portrayal of guilt and paranoia. It's been adapted into many films and is often included in high school literature curricula.
Ultimately, choosing a "most successful" work is subjective. But both "The Raven" and "The Tell-Tale Heart" stand as powerful examples of Poe's genius and continue to captivate audiences today.