Here's a breakdown:
Pros:
* Intriguing premise: The clash between Gotham City's dark knight and Mega-City One's lawman is inherently appealing.
* Strong art: The artwork by Carlos Ezquerra and John Higgins is praised for its gritty realism and capturing the distinct styles of both universes.
* Solid writing: The stories are well-paced and the dialogue is entertaining. The crossovers explore themes of justice, law, and the complexities of power.
* Good characterization: The characters are well-developed and true to their respective series.
Cons:
* Limited scope: Some fans feel the stories are slightly underwhelming considering the potential of the crossover.
* Inconsistencies: The stories sometimes struggle to fully integrate the two distinct universes, leading to some inconsistencies.
* Repetitive themes: The themes of law and order are explored heavily, which can feel repetitive to some readers.
Overall:
The "Batman/Judge Dredd" crossovers are worth checking out for fans of both characters. While they may not be masterpieces, they offer a fun, action-packed, and thought-provoking experience.
Whether or not they are "worth purchase" depends on your personal preferences. If you're looking for a unique and memorable crossover event, these comics might not be the best choice. However, if you enjoy gritty crime stories and the clash of two iconic law enforcers, then these comics could be worth your time.